470
A. Schlickmann et al.
Key words: Universities, Higher education,
Environmental education, Sustainable
development, Balanced Scorecard
(2) Environmental Education Axis
(1) Organizational Performance
Assessment Axis
Definition of Databases to Research (7)
Scopus, Web Of Science e ScienceDirect
ScienceDirect - 6.566 articles
(4)
"sustainability"
"enviromental"
"socioenvironmental"
(3) IES / Public Sector Axis
(6)
Keyword Compliance Test (10)
2º selected article: "A proposal of a Balanced
Scorecard for an environmental education
program at universities"
"universities"
"higuer education"
Keyword Combinations (8)
Search Database Articles (9)
Scopus - 21.190 articles
Define Search Axes (1), (2) and (3) and for each axis, define keywords (4), (5) and (6)
"measurement"
"assessment"
(5)
"college"
"management"
"university"
72 combinations
"evaluation"
"performance"
"measures"
1º selected article: "Measuring sustainability at
universities by means of the Sustainability
Tracking, Assessment and Rating System
(STARS): early findings from STARS data"
Key words: Sustainability, Climate change,
Higher education, STARS
Web Of Science - 6.202 articles
Fig. 5 Results for the Selection phase of the Raw Article Bank on environmental education
performance evaluation in HEIs. Source Research Data
multidisciplinarity (Dresch et al. 2019) and the adherence test showed convergence
with the keywords defined at the beginning of the study search. Figure 6 presents the
results for the article database filtering phase.
All 58 articles that make up the PB on environmental education performance
evaluation in HEIs, after analysis, presented the following information:
Concept
Input
Filter
Output
Filter 1 - Repeat ArƟcles
33.958
-24.136
9.822
Filter 2 - Title Alignment
9.822
-8.882
940
Filter 3 - ScienƟfic RecogniƟon (Cut: 10 CitaƟons)
940
-586
354
Filter 4 - Summary Alignment
354
-252
102
Filter 5 - Availability
157
-20
137
Filter 6 - Integral Alignment
137
-79
58
ApplicaƟon / Results
ArƟcle Bank Filtering
Recap ArƟcles without ScienƟfic RecogniƟon - 2017, 2018
and 2019 ArƟcles (Gross 282 ArƟcles)
102
53
155
Recap ArƟcles without ScienƟfic RecogniƟon - Authors'
ArƟcles from the Authors Bank (Gross 5 ArƟcles)
155
2
157
Fig. 6 Results for the filtering phase of the Environmental Education Performance Assessment
Article Bank in HEI. Source Research Data
A. Schlickmann et al.
Key words: Universities, Higher education,
Environmental education, Sustainable
development, Balanced Scorecard
(2) Environmental Education Axis
(1) Organizational Performance
Assessment Axis
Definition of Databases to Research (7)
Scopus, Web Of Science e ScienceDirect
ScienceDirect - 6.566 articles
(4)
"sustainability"
"enviromental"
"socioenvironmental"
(3) IES / Public Sector Axis
(6)
Keyword Compliance Test (10)
2º selected article: "A proposal of a Balanced
Scorecard for an environmental education
program at universities"
"universities"
"higuer education"
Keyword Combinations (8)
Search Database Articles (9)
Scopus - 21.190 articles
Define Search Axes (1), (2) and (3) and for each axis, define keywords (4), (5) and (6)
"measurement"
"assessment"
(5)
"college"
"management"
"university"
72 combinations
"evaluation"
"performance"
"measures"
1º selected article: "Measuring sustainability at
universities by means of the Sustainability
Tracking, Assessment and Rating System
(STARS): early findings from STARS data"
Key words: Sustainability, Climate change,
Higher education, STARS
Web Of Science - 6.202 articles
Fig. 5 Results for the Selection phase of the Raw Article Bank on environmental education
performance evaluation in HEIs. Source Research Data
multidisciplinarity (Dresch et al. 2019) and the adherence test showed convergence
with the keywords defined at the beginning of the study search. Figure 6 presents the
results for the article database filtering phase.
All 58 articles that make up the PB on environmental education performance
evaluation in HEIs, after analysis, presented the following information:
Concept
Input
Filter
Output
Filter 1 - Repeat ArƟcles
33.958
-24.136
9.822
Filter 2 - Title Alignment
9.822
-8.882
940
Filter 3 - ScienƟfic RecogniƟon (Cut: 10 CitaƟons)
940
-586
354
Filter 4 - Summary Alignment
354
-252
102
Filter 5 - Availability
157
-20
137
Filter 6 - Integral Alignment
137
-79
58
ApplicaƟon / Results
ArƟcle Bank Filtering
Recap ArƟcles without ScienƟfic RecogniƟon - 2017, 2018
and 2019 ArƟcles (Gross 282 ArƟcles)
102
53
155
Recap ArƟcles without ScienƟfic RecogniƟon - Authors'
ArƟcles from the Authors Bank (Gross 5 ArƟcles)
155
2
157
Fig. 6 Results for the filtering phase of the Environmental Education Performance Assessment
Article Bank in HEI. Source Research Data