43
Both methods have advantage and disadvantages (Table 2.8).
Developing monitoring plan shall consider following points:
• Be systematic: Information needs to be collected in the same manner over a
period of time for easy comparison.
• Ease of collection: It is prudent to avoid information that is difficult to collect
like satellite images of restricted and sensitive such as military establishment.
• Partnerships: Monitoring partners and their service charges like government
authority, government and academic institutions.
Table 2.9 shows examples of monitoring plans for evaluating HIA of transportation projects.
Evaluation of HIA should address the following questions:
1. Whether HIA recommendations are implemented or not
2. Whether HIA recommendations are accomplishing the expected results or not
The evaluations can be done with a pre-determined checklist, form, matrix, etc.
The evaluated results shall be informed to concerned authority to take corrective action.
Table 2.8 Example of advantages and disadvantages of different modes of public consultations
Particular
Open discussion
Advertise and correspond
Advantage
Disadvantage
Advantage
Disadvantage
Participation Will have
opportunity
to discuss
Due to limited time,
presentation of
issues elaborately
may not be possible
Stakeholder can
submit an elaborate
opinion
Will not have
opportunity to discuss
ambiguity
instantaneously. May
demand further
correspondence
Law and
order
–
May lead to public
strike,
demonstration at the
stake-holder
consultancy location
Will not have
problem of public
agitation, strike,
demonstration
during the
stakeholder
consultancy
–
Logistics
–
May result in
confusion if the
number of people
who attend the
consultation
exceeds expectation
Do not need
elaborate logistics
arrangement like
Making seating
arrangement to
stakeholders
Writing minute
dog meeting
Parking
arrangement
Arrange sufficient
toilets, drinking
water, first aid,
etc.
–
2.10 Health Monitoring Plan
Both methods have advantage and disadvantages (Table 2.8).
Developing monitoring plan shall consider following points:
• Be systematic: Information needs to be collected in the same manner over a
period of time for easy comparison.
• Ease of collection: It is prudent to avoid information that is difficult to collect
like satellite images of restricted and sensitive such as military establishment.
• Partnerships: Monitoring partners and their service charges like government
authority, government and academic institutions.
Table 2.9 shows examples of monitoring plans for evaluating HIA of transportation projects.
Evaluation of HIA should address the following questions:
1. Whether HIA recommendations are implemented or not
2. Whether HIA recommendations are accomplishing the expected results or not
The evaluations can be done with a pre-determined checklist, form, matrix, etc.
The evaluated results shall be informed to concerned authority to take corrective action.
Table 2.8 Example of advantages and disadvantages of different modes of public consultations
Particular
Open discussion
Advertise and correspond
Advantage
Disadvantage
Advantage
Disadvantage
Participation Will have
opportunity
to discuss
Due to limited time,
presentation of
issues elaborately
may not be possible
Stakeholder can
submit an elaborate
opinion
Will not have
opportunity to discuss
ambiguity
instantaneously. May
demand further
correspondence
Law and
order
–
May lead to public
strike,
demonstration at the
stake-holder
consultancy location
Will not have
problem of public
agitation, strike,
demonstration
during the
stakeholder
consultancy
–
Logistics
–
May result in
confusion if the
number of people
who attend the
consultation
exceeds expectation
Do not need
elaborate logistics
arrangement like
Making seating
arrangement to
stakeholders
Writing minute
dog meeting
Parking
arrangement
Arrange sufficient
toilets, drinking
water, first aid,
etc.
–
2.10 Health Monitoring Plan