56
Z. Amini et al.
Table 3.7
The value of the proposed measurements for each denoising method in datasets from Topcon device [16]
Original
2D CDL
2D DSDL 3D DSDL 2D
RCWDL
3D
RCWDL
2D
ICWDL
3D
ICWDL
2D SDWT 2D RCWT 2D CCWT 3D CCWT
CNR
3.09
±
1.35
24.24
±
10.63
28.09
±
10.19
78.83
±
33.20
24.25
±
10.61
88.91
±
32.00
24.26
±
10.63
86.91
±
31.49
14.66
±
6.60
26.51
±
11.55
34.67
±
15.28
55.06
±
23.47
EP
1
± 0
0.88
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.88
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.88
±
0.01
0.87
±
0.01
0.90
±
0.01
0.87
±
0.01
0.85
±
0.01
0.81
±
0.01
TP
1
± 0
0.18
±
0.03
0.17
±
0.04
0.19
±
0.05
0.18
±
0.04
0.14
±
0.03
0.18
±
0.04
0.13
±
0.03
0.23
±
0.03
0.13
±
0.02
0.09
±
0.02
0.06
±
0.02
ENL
28.69
±
0.49
2045.08
±
367.62
2183.56
±
423.96
19,059.32
±
9852.14
2047.14
±
364.41
22,231.73
±
354.43
2047.43
±
364.63
22,196.73
±
354.55
671.47
±
44.49
2316.04
±
430.29
4434.58
±
1270.34
8653.17
±
3846.45
Evaluation
time (s)
–
24.87
±
1.35
3.43
±
0.10
11.3
±
0.97
5.15
±
0.11
9.41
±
1.07
5.14
±
0.63
9.52
±
1.06
0.12
±
0.01
0.19
±
0.02
0.54
±
0.01
0.96
±
0.01
Z. Amini et al.
Table 3.7
The value of the proposed measurements for each denoising method in datasets from Topcon device [16]
Original
2D CDL
2D DSDL 3D DSDL 2D
RCWDL
3D
RCWDL
2D
ICWDL
3D
ICWDL
2D SDWT 2D RCWT 2D CCWT 3D CCWT
CNR
3.09
±
1.35
24.24
±
10.63
28.09
±
10.19
78.83
±
33.20
24.25
±
10.61
88.91
±
32.00
24.26
±
10.63
86.91
±
31.49
14.66
±
6.60
26.51
±
11.55
34.67
±
15.28
55.06
±
23.47
EP
1
± 0
0.88
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.88
±
0.01
0.86
±
0.01
0.88
±
0.01
0.87
±
0.01
0.90
±
0.01
0.87
±
0.01
0.85
±
0.01
0.81
±
0.01
TP
1
± 0
0.18
±
0.03
0.17
±
0.04
0.19
±
0.05
0.18
±
0.04
0.14
±
0.03
0.18
±
0.04
0.13
±
0.03
0.23
±
0.03
0.13
±
0.02
0.09
±
0.02
0.06
±
0.02
ENL
28.69
±
0.49
2045.08
±
367.62
2183.56
±
423.96
19,059.32
±
9852.14
2047.14
±
364.41
22,231.73
±
354.43
2047.43
±
364.63
22,196.73
±
354.55
671.47
±
44.49
2316.04
±
430.29
4434.58
±
1270.34
8653.17
±
3846.45
Evaluation
time (s)
–
24.87
±
1.35
3.43
±
0.10
11.3
±
0.97
5.15
±
0.11
9.41
±
1.07
5.14
±
0.63
9.52
±
1.06
0.12
±
0.01
0.19
±
0.02
0.54
±
0.01
0.96
±
0.01
