308
M. Noura et al.
Table 2 Other ontology-based IoT automotive projects that cannot be employed since ontologies
are not available (even upon request)
Authors
Year
Expertise
OA
Reasoning
Wetterwald et al. [10]
2019
SAREF4AUTO
×
×
Katsumi et al. [7]
2018
Survey – 11 ontology referenced ×
×
Fernandez et al. [27]
2016
Automatic traffic lights settings
×
×
Armand et al. [6]
2014
Renault: driving assitance
×
14 SWRL rules
Villalba et al. [8, 28, 29]
2014
VEACON: vehicular accident
×
–
CAOVA: Car accident for
VANETs
×
–
Stocker et al. [30] [31]
2014
Road vehicle classification
×
Rule-based inference
(vehicle type)
Ebers et al. [32]
2013
VANETs ontology
×
×
Mnasser, De Oliveria, Houda,
Zidi et al. [33–36]
2013
Transportation ontology
×
Jess engine for SWRL
rules
Li et al. [37]
2012
Car ontology (in chinese)
×
×
Calavia et al. [38]
2012
Traffic ontology
×
Semantic reasoning,
SWRL rules
Madkour et al. [39]
2011
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
×
Hamilton et al. [40]
2013
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
Pellet, SWRL, Jess
Feld, Muller et al. [41]
2011
Automative, distance between
cars
×
×
Wang et al. [42]
2011
Traffic accident ontology
×
×
Hulsen et al. [43]
2011
Ontology for driver assistance
×
RacerPro
Berdier et al. [44]
2011
Ontology for Urban mobility
×
×
Kannan et al. [45]
2010
Intelligent driver
×
Pellet reasoner
(consistency)
Assistance system for vehicle
Baumgartner et al. [46]
2010
Ontology for situation awareness ×
10 rules
Liu et al. [47]
2010
Road surveillance system
×
SWRL rules (inform, alert)
Niaraki et al. [48]
2009
personalized route planning
×
×
Yue et al. [49]
2009
Traffic accident
×
×
Zhai et al. [50]
2009
Traffic information
×
(dryness, dampness)
Sun et al. [51]
2009
Smart car
×
×
Belhadef et al. [52]
2009
Urban geographical information
system
×
×
Regele et al. [53]
2008
Autonomous driving system:
trajectory planning, traffic
coordination
×
×
Mair, Eigner et al. [54]
2008
Collision avoidance in VANETs
×
×
Ontology (in German)
Cheng et al. [55]
2008
Transportation
×
Ontology-based reasoning
(Racer) rule-based reasoning
(Jess, LISP, SWRLJessTab)
Hu et al. [56]
2007
Oil
×
×
Lorenz et al. [57]
2005
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
×
Legend Ontology Availability (OA)
M. Noura et al.
Table 2 Other ontology-based IoT automotive projects that cannot be employed since ontologies
are not available (even upon request)
Authors
Year
Expertise
OA
Reasoning
Wetterwald et al. [10]
2019
SAREF4AUTO
×
×
Katsumi et al. [7]
2018
Survey – 11 ontology referenced ×
×
Fernandez et al. [27]
2016
Automatic traffic lights settings
×
×
Armand et al. [6]
2014
Renault: driving assitance
×
14 SWRL rules
Villalba et al. [8, 28, 29]
2014
VEACON: vehicular accident
×
–
CAOVA: Car accident for
VANETs
×
–
Stocker et al. [30] [31]
2014
Road vehicle classification
×
Rule-based inference
(vehicle type)
Ebers et al. [32]
2013
VANETs ontology
×
×
Mnasser, De Oliveria, Houda,
Zidi et al. [33–36]
2013
Transportation ontology
×
Jess engine for SWRL
rules
Li et al. [37]
2012
Car ontology (in chinese)
×
×
Calavia et al. [38]
2012
Traffic ontology
×
Semantic reasoning,
SWRL rules
Madkour et al. [39]
2011
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
×
Hamilton et al. [40]
2013
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
Pellet, SWRL, Jess
Feld, Muller et al. [41]
2011
Automative, distance between
cars
×
×
Wang et al. [42]
2011
Traffic accident ontology
×
×
Hulsen et al. [43]
2011
Ontology for driver assistance
×
RacerPro
Berdier et al. [44]
2011
Ontology for Urban mobility
×
×
Kannan et al. [45]
2010
Intelligent driver
×
Pellet reasoner
(consistency)
Assistance system for vehicle
Baumgartner et al. [46]
2010
Ontology for situation awareness ×
10 rules
Liu et al. [47]
2010
Road surveillance system
×
SWRL rules (inform, alert)
Niaraki et al. [48]
2009
personalized route planning
×
×
Yue et al. [49]
2009
Traffic accident
×
×
Zhai et al. [50]
2009
Traffic information
×
(dryness, dampness)
Sun et al. [51]
2009
Smart car
×
×
Belhadef et al. [52]
2009
Urban geographical information
system
×
×
Regele et al. [53]
2008
Autonomous driving system:
trajectory planning, traffic
coordination
×
×
Mair, Eigner et al. [54]
2008
Collision avoidance in VANETs
×
×
Ontology (in German)
Cheng et al. [55]
2008
Transportation
×
Ontology-based reasoning
(Racer) rule-based reasoning
(Jess, LISP, SWRLJessTab)
Hu et al. [56]
2007
Oil
×
×
Lorenz et al. [57]
2005
Ontology of transportation
networks
×
×
Legend Ontology Availability (OA)